Re: How good is War Command?

Ginger I cannot take you seriously as a poster, I don’t think you can even remember what you say from one post to the next. For example you said:-

You are just making things up about Timeform Steve. Deliberately making up stuff to suit your opinion.

Now you are saying:-

<p style="color: #0000FF]I asked where you got the 4 stars from Steve. I did

not

accuse you of making it up!

That seems clear cut enough that the second statement is incorrect.

I have been aiming my posts here at Timeform and not at yourself. I brought your observations on War Command into the thread to demonstrate what high regard some people held him in and how they must have been disappointed that he had been beaten and had drifted in the 2000 Guineas as a result of it.

Indocine thought my opinion regarding War Command in the Phoenix was rubbish and that is his right. However, he has been decent enough and brought to the table the fact that the Railway Stakes was upgraded retrospectively. Had Sudirman been on the upgrade with only 2lbs improvement required to win the Phoenix it begs the question as to why War Command was 2/5, I am sure the official ratings had War Command on 119 and Sudirman on 110 before the Phoenix and that is why I said he needed good improvement.

I have always thought this forum should be about the respecting its users and not worrying about defending a profit making organisation like Timeform, who are being paid and put themselves up for criticism by that fact.

I have seen you badgering TAPK on another thread, demanding an apology for Timeform from him. Therefore it is not wise to accuse me of having a hissy fit over what is personal criticism, which you now deny making, when you yourself have been apoplectic with rage on behalf of a company.

All of this is pointless, as you will never concede that you might have been wrong. You are happy to come on here and accuse jockey James Doyle of being a cheat and then throw the toys out of the pram when the beloved Timeform are criticised.

As they say on Dragon’s Den, "For that reason, I’m out"